Don’t know where you guys take case suggestions but the case of George Franklin and his daughter Eileen’s repressed memory would be super interesting to cover and I wonder what you guys think!

Love them both!

Very good! Hosts are so good together. Stories are interesting, can’t wait to hear more.

I just got done listening to all the episodes over the past month. I love hearing about all the different cases and I love the hosts dynamic. They’re great at telling each story and they balance out each sober story with their humor. Love hearing them chat.

Absolutely LOVE the stories, and what the podcast is supposed to be. However, I can’t stand (and this happens constantly) the long side conversations they have. Even through some of the episodes they’ll make comments about how “I’m sure the creepers are saying hurrying up and go to the next story). I literally find myself saying that very thing be quite and start the next story. Again the. Podcast itself (stories are great). I just wish they wouldn’t talk so much in between stories and while telling them.

With one of the best intros to a Podcast ever (You Can’t Trust County) and a perfect chemistry between Stew and Silas, CREEPTIME has quickly become one of my go to Podcasts during my daily walks. Each story is unique and well told by both hosts. Sign me up, because I’m a fan.

I’m giving it two stars because I love sylas and could listen to him tell me stories all day. But I cannot with stew. Every single episode, after every single big part of the story, she says “I was going to say that’s what happened.” I legit call it every single time sylas tells her to get ready for what he has to tell her about a case. It’s so annoying. I’m sorry but she is insufferable.

Just got through ep. 135 with you guys and have listened to literally everything you all have on the Apple podcast. I must say that this podcast is a top 3 essential podcast to listen to if you like the weird and wild solved/ unsolved crimes. I feel you Silas on being a human when you broke down a little during ep. 135 but ep. 119 on Alison Botha is seared in my head. Some of the best banter and storytelling on any podcast platform. Thank you for what you do and the entertainment. You both are awesome and please! Come to Detroit! I’d love to go to one of your live shows!

I’ve absolutely loved listening to the podcast for a few years now. The dynamic between Sylas and Stew is genuine and great to hear! The deep dives on the cases are so well done and very respectful!❤️❤️

Just got home from your live tour performance in Sacramento! Had a great time! Looking forward to binging all your past episodes!

You guys are too hilarious. I literally listen to your podcasts every day on my walks/runs. I can’t count how many times I’ve stopped in my tracks to die laughing or because I’m legitimately stunned. You guys should do a podcast on Tara Grinstead!

I wanted to love this so much. Hosts don’t do as much research as they should though and I know things are tough right now (gestures wildly at everything) but I almost feel like they make fun of cultures and places they’ve never been to or don’t really get and that rubs me the wrong way. LA is great but it doesn’t mean you have to be condescending to other places. I say this with as much kindness and love as possible.

Sylas and Stew, Your podcast is part of my daily routine, and I will often relisten to some of the older episodes as well! No matter what I do— cleaning, driving, or even just needing some sound to fall asleep— you guys are my go-to! On December 13th 2024, my daughter, Lucia came into this world, and BABY, you guys were part of that too. Although I had an amazing support system, your podcast also contributed to keeping me in good spirits and helped keep my mind occupied from the pain. Thank you for not only bringing light to these cases but for brining some joy into them as well. Love you guys!

I love this show but sometimes I can’t hear them talking at all, so I turn my sound up and then it gets super loud! So I turn it down, and again, can’t hear you! Such a good show, and I love the content. Is the audio problem just me?!

I was searching for a Halloween theme scary story podcast around October and creep time popped up so I played it. The scariest true story of a man living in a girls vent shook me to my core but Sylas and stews banter and comedy was so fun I started listening to more and then more and then more. As a fellow theatre kid myself they make me laugh and feel like I’m hanging out with old friends

I found out about this podcast on Reddit about a week ago and since then I’ve been binging all episodes. I work a super boring job where I’m predominantly alone the majority of the time. I love listening to Sylas and Stew because I feel like they’re friends working right beside me and they bring such a sense of comfort. Sylas is such a good story teller and is so captivating, Stew is so funny and relatable. I have to stifle my laughter so much since I work in a quiet office. Plus the stories they tell are so sinister and insidious and just creepy enough. I appreciate you both so much and I love the podcast!

I’ve listened to many podcasts over the years. But, CreepTime is by far my favorite. The banter between Sylas and Stew, the cases that are covered, and the way they go in depth discussing theories makes me feel like I’m part of the conversation. As a mental health professional of 20+ years (as well as being an ex correctional officer of 6 years, and police officer’s daughter), I tend to talk out loud at the podcast, or even nod along as they say things that are accurate about the thought processes of the people behind the crimes. I just love, love this pod. I recommend it to everyone I talk to.

I love that it’s like you guys are telling me a story that you know of, instead of it being script. Idk how to explain it it’s the best lol!

I legit don’t think words can explain how much I love this podcast! These two incredible humans have gotten me through some really rough days. With their amazing humor, ambition for the stories, passion for their followers and over all joy of everything, they just make life better. I have re-listened to every episode many times over and will continue to everyday. I can go on and on and on about how much I love this podcast but I’ll just say to everyone that this is THE true crime podcast and no one could EVER do it better than Creeptime can!

First off love you guys, your dynamic and the content. I’m having some issues with the audio though, since I listen to it while driving it’s hard to hear Sylas’ voice esp when he’s reading, and I miss certain parts. I don’t know if he’s too quiet and his voice drops off or he’s too far away from the mic. And then Stew is very close to the mic so I keep having to adjust the volume! But otherwise five stars!

Best duo in podcasting!

I’m so glad I came across your podcast. I listen while I cook, clean, or I just want to tune my husband out 😂 I love y’all so much! Some of the stories have scared the heck it of me! Like the The missing 411… lord just typing this I’m getting scared 😱 but y’all are amazing 🤩 On a side note I’m expecting and I’m trying to convince my husband if we have a boy to give him the middle name Sylas. Such a beautiful name.

I started listening a few months ago and you made it to my top 2 favorite true crime podcasts.

I love this podcast! Y’all crack me up and I’ve had to turn away from my lash clients multiple times and try to swallow my cackle. Appreciate your light hearted, Nancy grace, banter.

The title is a little inside joke, but wow do Slyas and Stew truly make you feel like the third friend in the room. I listen to your podcast on repeat and hope to catch the tour as well. Keep being absolutely fabulous both of you and thank so much for caring so much for creepers. We love you 🫶🏻

Stop supporting satanist.

Love this podcast. I listen to this podcast on the drive home but I’ve also gotten used to falling asleep to it. I need ambient noise or conversation to fall asleep. I think it’s where my parents would take me to my families houses. I would fall asleep to them talking or playing music. I learned very young to just go to sleep if need be. Yes that makes me weird but the soothing voices of Stew and Sylas just lull me to sleep. I know it’s horrible but I love their voices.

Been listening to creeptime for a while now. These episodes get me through my shifts at night. Love it. However, please please please check mic levels. The open mouth cackling almost blew my eardrums from the volume spike. lol keep up the good you two!

Not a fan of the ambience of this podcast. I was expecting something like the Facebook videos. This is definitely not a night time podcast. Unfortunately I’m not vibing with Stew. There is a lot of filler talk… like “get back to the story. Get to the point!!” This is worse than the Sinister podcast.

I have listened to a lot of podcasts about true crime, mysteries and creepy things, however Creeptime is by far the BEST! I have watched Sylas Dean on TikTok for a long time and have always loved his energy and his charisma. Between him and Stew, the commentary is hilarious yet informative. I find myself laughing out loud when I listen to them together. I cannot express how much I love this podcast. Sylas and Stew are an incredible team, and I hope they never stop doing this amazing podcast!

Girl, I have listened to every single episode, some of them twice. I have submitted stories myself and now I pay for premium. Sylas is such a phenomenal story teller. He and Stew both make me feel like I’m in the room with them watching Sylas with a flashlight to his face, me and Stew sitting opposite of him biting our nails and hiding behind a pillow. I feel like another bestie who is joining in on the banter and feel absolutely captivated by the case at hand. This is one of the VERY BEST podcasts in history. Thank you Sylas Dean and Stew, love you both 🤍

Ok well hello! I have only become part of the creeper community recently possibly late August 2024 to today when im posting this, i even went and created a reddit to follow a long. I immediately fell into the rabbit hole with both of you. I came across an instagram post from the creeper podcast and thats what got me hooked, then I saw in my feed on tik tok one of Sylas’s videos and it was the point of no return. I went to college and elected Psychology as my major, the study of human behavior and why totally fascinating and go through these true crime stories theories conspiracies really hooks me in. All the ifs buts whys hows make me look like the gif if the lady doing math in her head trying to figure it out or ask my self did they do this ask about this what about that ect. Stew you are amazing! You add the cherry on top to the whole story telling. You are both so insync with each other its enjoyable to hear you both, i had started to listen from the most recent back, then chose to go back and start at episode 1, still have about 89 to catch up but ill get there its been a journey for sure! Listen to you on my way to work at lunch on my way home from work or on my break. Truly appreciate the light heartedness added to such tragic stories, as its better to process/digest. The costumes for the Halloween youtube videos were amazing great job. Hope to continue listening to you both for years to come. Truly appreciate you both

Absolutely obsessed with you guys. I have been into the paranormal and true crime for a while now. I randomly came across Creeptime here on my podcast app and it was love at first listen! I am now a lifetime CREEPER!!!!! Keep em comin!!!!!!! 🤯👀💀👻🎃

I tried to hang in there with these 2… the longer I listen the more I can’t do it with their new episodes. There is A LOT of talking about nothing before the actual episode begins about their personal life or the entertainment media… It’s becoming more clearer that these 2 are in this only for fame. And getting their name out on the internet so they can expand their working opportunities. This is a pretty new show for the fame monsters to start coming out this early. Also, there will be a lot of not so subtle drops of getting the listener to buy tickets to their tours and it will happen even in mid episode. Don’t get me wrong, I was really rooting for this show in the beginning of their journey. Unfortunately the tune of the show doesn’t seem like they really care about the crime, victims families and the actual victims with all their giggling, laughing, ad selling, “buy my tickets to my tour!”, and side track stories while they are attempting to tell the story. It’s awful.

I am a fan of true crime and spooky stories. Sylas and Stu are fun to listen to, it’s rare that they don’t make me laugh. I like their approach to the subject matter, and the time they take for each podcast. While I do listen to other similar podcasts, Creeptime is one of my favorites, so much so that I became a premium. Thank you Sylas and Stu for your show! You have at least one fan in Puerto Rico! 😊

The hosts are really funny but they don’t do enough research. Instead of sharing facts they share rumors.

Update Oct 2024 — I still absolutely love the personalities of Sylas and Stew, but the research is really lacking. Or at least the fact checking. From reporting that the ransom photo of Samantha Koenig circulated online was the real image when it was actually a recreation for a documentary — to saying Ann Rule dated Bundy… These stories are too important to spread inaccuracies. I’d love if they leaned into creepy stories more since those don’t require the same amount of accuracy and they’re both wonderful storytellers. I gotta give five stars for the consistency of the ice cream truck driver. I found this podcast off of reddit, and I’ve been really enjoying binging. Well researched while still having levity in their episodes

This POD is by far my fave true crime. I love the dynamic between Stew and Sylas. You two are hilarious and always know the right time to throw in a “Baby!” Seriously Sylas you need to curse that ice cream man. I cannot even tell you how many times I’ve jumped at that sound. 🤣 Keep being you and bringing theses cases to light!

Dear god…I often can’t get through the first 10 minutes. The banter back and forth, the loud open mouth laughs, the off topics. I can’t do to. Stories (once we get to them) are great. Focus on that and this podcast would be wonderful.

I’ve been pretty burned out on true crime recently but was curious if there were any new shows out there, so I threw on an episode of Creeptime. OBSESSED! I’ve now listened to five randomly-selected episodes and every single one has been a banger, even in cases where I already knew the story. Super well-researched but still so fun, will be spending the next few weeks in a rabbit hole listening to all the eps.

Love love love Sylas and Stew! They are lovely people and have such a great dynamic! BUT I just listened to the Menendez case and the research was just not there. When Stew said Lyle wrote a book I was like girlllll that is not what happened he isn’t even the author of that book babe. I will say that case is a tough one, and would likely need to be a two parter but there was so many crucial aspects not covered. But I do think both Stew and Sylas have so much respect for the victims of their cases so I love them! Just need to maybe get a little better at research!

Between CreepTime and CreepTime: After Dark you guys have gotten me through a lot and are my favorite! We had a house fire on Christmas Eve and you both felt like friends that helped get us through it by taking our minds off of it. I recommend this show to everyone, my family and I really love both shows! Thank you for all your hard work! Just want everyone to enjoy this show!

Being a Texan born woman who now lives on the west coast, I LOVE THE ACCENTS. So comforting in the middle of all the creep lol. I often am listening late at night, home alone 😅 y’all are seriously my favorite. I have many favorite things about this podcast but my most favorite is how respectful y’all are, while still being funny and just saying what is already on everyone’s minds 😂 also, Jack Dillon is welcome back anytime, his complete unhinged behavior is the best. I’ve commented on your YouTube videos, and the fact you’ve responded meant so much! Thank you for being so interactive. I’m gunna stop, cause I’m totally fan-girling. ❤️❤️ If you’re reading this and trying to decide to listen, I recommend starting from the very beginning!! The running jokes are just too good. Gilly hicks has been my fav 😂😂😂 Sylas and Stew are just such great performers while still being down to earth. I’ve tried other true crime podcasts and none of them hit like this one.

THE BEST PODCAST FOR TRUE CRIME!! Love the unsolved mysteries and disappearances the most! Subscribed to premium after just one episode! Creeper 4 life 🧡🖤

I’m so thankful for you all. Listening to yall has gotten me through a hysterectomy removing cancer from my body. Then 4 weeks later my dad passed’s away. This caused me to become my mom’s full time caregiver (later stages dementia). To Now sitting in a shower after 6 days in ICU now to day 2 in regular room of recoverying from an Open Mesenteric (Heart & Intestinal) surgery. You all were the only ones that could keep my focus when the pain of each thing got super intense. I probably could have made it without you but then there may have been a case about me. Lol 😉😉Thank you and congratulations on the live.

Love love love!!!!

10/10 would recommend.

obsessed with these guys, love that they try to stay objective and are easy to listen to for hours on end. they also imo do a good job of being respectful to the victims and although they get silly they also swing back to serious and emphasize gravity if the situations. an early pod said Elisa Lam was a poll option, IM STILL WAITING FOR IT!!! a good thing about this pod is i can listen to cases i know pretty well and 1) get info i didn’t know before and 2) enjoy my time listening. i’d love to hear an elisa lam ep!! EDIT: a lot of podcasts i get so annoyed listening to because i am internally SCREAMING something that they don’t know or it seems obvious especially if they did research on that case!! haven’t had the problem with these guys after 100+ episodes :)

My daughter Mallory and her girl friend told me I’d love yall and they were right!! Love the banter and the silliness sometimes you need a little lightness.

I started binge listening to this about a month ago, and I’m almost caught up to recent episodes! The energy you two give off is so welcoming and it feels like I’m there with you hanging out, talking about cases!