This is one of my top three podcasts I listen too, discovered it about a month ago and cannot stop listening! They turn usually dark topics, into comedy, while still slightly creeping you out. It’s the perfect balance!

I don’t know why previous reviewers were expecting academic level research from the podcast but if you are looking for informative comedy, you’ve come to the right place! I enjoy Sara and Emily’s banter and they have a well curated list of subjects covered.

This podcast feels like eavesdropping on a conversation between friends, complete with mouth noises, “we’ll edit that out”, and lazy, off the cuff research. The hosts think they’re verrrrrry funny despite every low hanging fruit joke ringing hollow.

Emily and Sarah!! Thank you both so much for this podcast! We stumbled upon it on a road trip and now it’s our go to for long car rides!! We feel like we are just con with friends in the car, laughing along with you both! We love the spooky episodes the most! Please keep them coming! -Gracie + Mang

Stumbled upon this gem on a long car ride, and now we listen to it on every road trip! These two provide fun and witty humor, and we’ve had a blast learning various fun facts from them. (Sara and Emily, if you’re reading this... Hey ladies:) We heard in your Mothman episode that a couple bad apples brought your rating down to 3.5 stars, and that simply won’t do. Hope this helps!) Bye, we love you too! ~ G & Mang

:)

Got 3 minutes into the first time listening. Can’t do it. Immature reactions to intense topics and the hosts are all over the place. Not worth the time.

Saw an episode on a subject I’m researching but I couldn’t listen longer than a few minutes. Obnoxious, ignorant, and vapid. Back to real research.

These ladies are pretty great and hilarious. Very glad to have stumbled upon them.

This podcast is so much fun. I’ve only Listened to a few so far but I’m looking forward to the rest!

These two put on a great show. The content is interesting and entertaining. I really like it and am glad this show exists! Thank you!

Proof that just because you can make a podcast doesn’t mean you should.

Very entertaining, informative, and just enough creepiness! My favorite podcast!

Very funny and random and sometimes unsettling ie the strange noises episode.

As a criminologist, more than half of their claims are false. They talk about the incompetence of individuals like in the Missing 411 episode but aren’t even competent enough to research the topic correctly without their ignorant bias. It’s unfortunate how bad this podcast is.

The laughed at serious subjects talking about them as jokes. I didn’t like this at all. Made fun of other people’s hard work.

Awesome random facts with an appropriate amount of laughing about random things. @michaelaburnley47

I never bother to write anything in the review, but this is unbearable to listen to. Tried two episodes, on top of constant giggling and nonsense talk it seems like they don’t even bother with basic research , let alone the deeper aspects that one expects from a podcast.

Very fun and a great primer for a lot of topics!

Completely uninformed and not entertaining at all, won’t be coming back

I listened to this to do some research on Salem Witch Trials, I’m convinced they know nothing of the topic other than what they googled. Their opinions asserted and dragging on of pointless info made me never want to listen again.

We are trying to listen to the missing 411 and they are laughing nonstop about nothing funny and inside jokes. They admit to never reading any of the books or watching the movie so I’m not sure what makes them qualified to talk about this mystery...

It’s a great show except when they Skype!

This was painful to listen to! These girls think they are being cute and funny, but just come off as an annoying ditzy pair. Wanted to like this based on the interesting topics covered but couldn’t get through even one episode.

Just discovered this podcast, good humor but always interesting topics. I’ve binged this entire series in 2 days so I’m ready for more

Sounds I never ever wish to hear again. Absolutely the worst.

Just millennial ditz’s displaying awful speaking skills brushing over history terribly. If you release episodes about history why even bother if you don’t care about the content.

I used one of their old podcast entitled Salem Witch Trials for notes on my History Fair project and it really helped me get an idea of what happened during this time. I'll definitely be listening to them again.

I love this podcast SO much! The hosts are knowledgeable and hilarious. My absolute favorite podcast.

A really fun podcast with very interesting topics, it's one of the only podcasts that I listen to consistently. Very down to earth and humorous, highly recommend! 💖

I've really dig this show. I listen to a bunch of pods about weird stuff and most of the time it devolves into just rambling, but the hosts of this show clearly know their stuff and research lots. Can't wait for more!

The topics are really interesting and are a wide range. I also enjoy how the hosts do more research than just Wikipedia the topic.

I really wanted to like this podcast because the topics covered are really interesting but it's just not executed well.

FYI. A hide behind is nothing like a Native American skinwalker.

Afternoonified is quickly becoming one of my favorite podcasts and having to wait two weeks for new episodes is physically painful sometimes. The hosts are hilarious, the topics are always super interesting, and I can't wait to see what they come up with next!